Rare entries contest 2: results

  • Dear all,


    Below are the results of the second Jules Verne Rare Entries Contest. There were 11 participants this time, two more than in the first round. I have many questions in stock, so I hope to run a third round in the near future.


    Best regards,
    Garmt.



    Ranking


    RANK SCORE ENTRANT Q0 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q5 Q6 Q7 Q8 Q9


    1. 1500 Marko Obradovic 5 1 1 3 1 2 5 5 2 1
    2. 2400 Françoise Schiltz 5 6 1 2 2 1 5 2 2 1
    3. 3240 Ariel Pérez 1 6 3 1 1 1 3 5 3 WR
    4. 3600 Alain Braut 5 6 1 1 2 2 3 WR 1 1
    5. 6600 Jean-Luc Pruvost 5 WR 1 1 2 6 5 2 1 1
    6. 9000 Stefan Marniok 5 6 3 2 2 1 5 5 1 1
    7. 48600 Bernhard Krauth 5 6 3 1 1 6 3 5 3 2
    8. 59400 David McCallister 5 WR 1 3 2 6 1 5 3 2
    9. 475200 Ralf Tauchmann 5 WR 3 1 2 6 2 WR 3 WR
    10. 972000 Christian Sánchez 5 6 3 3 2 6 5 WR 3 2
    11. 1425600 David Vasek 5 WR 3 WR 2 6 2 WR 3 2


    These are the answers given by the top 3 entrants:


    Marko Obradovic Françoise Schiltz Ariel Pérez
    0 Anna Anna Marie
    1 Leo XIII Raymond Poincaré Raymond Poincaré
    2 Cyrus Smith Harbert Nab
    3 Jules Verne De Rotterdam à Copenhague Zigzags à travers la science
    4 Sicily Stromboli Formentera
    5 Pierce Brosnan William Desmond Conrad Veidt
    6 Arthur Gordon Pym Arthur Gordon Pym Der Schweizerische Robinson
    7 L'Etoile du Sud Les 500 millions L'Etoile du Sud
    8 Budapest Budapest Zürich
    9 Len and William Guy Marc and Henry Vidal Natalis and Irma Delpierre


    Ansers given


    Here are the answers given to each question, ranked from most to least popular, i.e. worst to best, for each question:


    | 0. Give the name of a brother or sister of Jules Verne.


    5 Anna (1837-1919)
    5 Mathilde (1839-1920)
    1 Marie (1842-1913)


    While it is understandable that people avoided the "obvious" answer Paul, I can't explain why Marie was mentioned only once and her sisters five times each.


    | 1. Name a person who, at some moment in his life, was the head of state of a European country, and with whom Jules Verne corresponded, or talked in person. The correspondence or conversation does not have to have taken place at the time when the person was head of state.


    6 Raymond Poincaré (Advocate in case Turpin; president of France
    1913-1920.)
    1 Leo XIII (Apparently received Verne in 1884; pope 1878-1903.)
    WRONG:
    2 Aristide Briand (No head of state)
    1 - (No answer given)
    1 Adolphe Thiers (No meeting or correspondence)


    The entrant who said Adolphe Thiers couldn't find his source anymore. I have searched a couple of sources, but could not find any indication that Verne and Thiers ever met or corresponded.
    Verne did meet Aristide Briand in the 1870s, but Briand was never head of state of France. He was prime minister many times, but the French head of state is the
    president, a position Briand never achieved.
    Another answer I would have accepted as correct is Leopold II, who was king of Belgium from 1865 to 1909. It seems Jules Verne was received by Leopold II during his tour through Belgium and the Netherlands in 1887, although there is no clear evidence that this meeting did in fact take place.


    | 2. Name a character who lived on the island Lincoln in the novel L'Ile mystérieuse.


    3 Ayrton
    3 Nab
    1 Cyrus Smith
    1 Gédéon Spilett
    1 Harbert
    1 Pencroff
    1 Top


    Although Top is a dog, I accept him as a character.
    A correct answer that wasn't given is of course Nemo. Also, nobody seems to have thought of the pirates who roamed Lincoln Island for a while.



    | 3. Name a work by a relative of Jules Verne, which was published under the author's own name.


    3 Jules Verne (by Jean Jules-Verne, Verne's grandson)
    2 De Rotterdam à Copenhague à bord du yacht à vapeur Saint-Michel
    (by Paul Verne, Verne's brother)
    1 La Navigation à voiles et à vapeur (by Michel Verne, Verne's
    son)
    1 Quarantième ascension française au Mont-Blanc (by Paul Verne,
    Verne's brother)
    1 Trouvez votre étoile (by Danielle Verne, Verne's
    great-grandniece)
    1 Un express de l'avenir (By Michel Verne, Verne's son)
    1 Zigzags à travers la science (by Michel Verne, Verne's son)
    WRONG:
    1 L´Etonnante aventure de la mission Barsac (Published under
    Jules Verne's name)


    The text "La Navigation à voiles et à vapeur" was discovered only recently by Volker Dehs. It was published by Editeur Henri Gautier in Paris, in "Bibliothèque Scientifique des Ecoles & des familles", the year of publication is unknown (probably 1900 - 1920).


    | 4. Name an island in the Mediterranean that is described in a work by Jules Verne in more than one paragraph.


    2 Julia (Mirifiques Aventures de Maître Antifer)
    2 Mallorca (Clovis Dardentor)
    2 Malta (Mathias Sandorf)
    2 Stromboli (Voyage au Centre de la Terre)
    1 Corfu (L'Archipel en Feu)
    1 Formentera (Hector Servadac)
    1 Sicily (Mathias Sandorf)


    | 5. Name an actor who played Phileas Fogg in an adaptation of Jules Verne's novel Le Tour du Monde en 80 Jours.


    6 David Niven (Movie "Around the World in 80 Days", 1956)
    2 Pierce Brosnan (TV series "Around the World in 80 Days", 1989)
    1 Conrad Veidt (Movie "Die Reise um die Erde in 80 Tagen", 1919)
    1 Steve Coogan (Movie "Around the World in 80 Days", 2004)
    1 William Desmond (Phileas Fogg III in movie "Around the World
    in 18 Days", 1923)


    There have been many adaptations of this novel, on the big screen, on television, and on stage, from Verne's own theatre version (first staged in 1874) to the movie with Steve Coogan and Jackie Chan that will premiere in a few weeks. Dozens, if not hundreds, of actors have played Phileas Fogg, and even though most of them are completely unknown today, I was amazed to see so many entrants mention the most famous Fogg, David Niven.


    | 6. Name a novel that Jules Verne wrote a sequel to.


    5 The narrative of Arthur Gordon Pym (Le Sphinx des Glaces)
    3 Der Schweizerische Robinson (Seconde Patrie)
    2 Les Enfants du capitaine Grant (L'Ile mystérieuse)
    1 Robur-le-Conquérant (Maître du Monde)


    There are two novels by other authors (both highly admired by Jules Verne) that he wrote a sequel to; both of these were mentioned. Verne also wrote sequels to some of his own novels. The correct answers that weren't given are De la Terre à la Lune, Autour de la Lune and Vingt mille lieues sous les mers. One could argue that Voyage à travers l'impossible is a sequel to Voyages et Aventures du capitaine Hatteras, so I would have accepted that answer as well.


    | 7. Name a Voyage Extraordinaire that was written in collaboration with André Laurie.


    5 L'Etoile du Sud
    2 Les cinq cents millions de la Bégum
    WRONG:
    4 L'Epave du Cynthia (not a Voyage Extraordinaire)


    L'Epave du Cynthia was not part of the Voyages Extraordinaires, and since the question asked for a "Voyage Extraordinaire" rather than a "work" in general, this answer is wrong.
    One of the entrants who answered "L'Etoile du Sud" remarked that that was never a "real" collaboration with André Laurie. Indeed, Verne and Laurie didn't work
    together like Verne did with D'Ennery to write some of his plays, but since both Laurie and Verne worked on this novel, I consider this a collaboration.


    | 8. Name a city where a restaurant or bar called 'Jules Verne' can be found.


    3 Paris (Restaurant Jules Verne, on the Eiffel Tower)
    3 Zürich (Jules Verne Panorama Bar, Uraniastrasse 9)
    2 Budapest (Club Verne, V. Váci Utca 60)
    1 Genève (Restaurant Jules Verne, Rue Jean-Violette 20)
    1 Quiberon (Restaurant Le Jules Verne, 43 rue de Port Haliguen)
    1 Skagen (Restaurant Jules Verne, Havneplads 4)


    ... to name but a few!


    | 9. Name two brothers who are both characters in a work by Jules Verne.


    2 Jean and Sandre Cascabel (César Cascabel)
    2 Karl and Pieter Kip (Les Frères Kip)
    1 Czar of Russia and Grand Duke (Michel Strogoff)
    1 Len and William Guy (Le Sphinx des Glaces)
    1 Marc and Henry Vidal (Le Secret de Wilhelm Storitz)
    1 Nana Sahib and Balao Rao (La Maison à Vapeur)
    1 Sam and Sib Melvill (Le Rayon Vert)
    WRONG:
    1 Natalis and Irma Delpierre (brother and sister)
    1 Nord contre Sud (not two brothers)

  • Zitat

    Original von Poldi
    Garmt, wo bleibt Runde 3? ;) :D :harhar:


    Ist schon fertig, aber ich werde sie erst spater publizieren. Zuerst muss man sich ein bisschien erholen konnen!

  • Das ist schwierig, denn nicht jeder Spieler spielt in allen Runden mit. Und es gibt Runden in den man einfach viele Punkte bekommt (wie diese 2. Runde: die Geschwister Jules Vernes und die Zusammenarbeit mit Laurie haben nur 4 bzw. 2 richtige Antworten). Macht jemand in solch eine 'schwierige' Runde nicht mit, so bekommt er einfach eine gute Position im allgemeinen Ranking. Und je mehr Leute in einer Runde teilnehmen, desto mehr Punkte bekommen sie durchschnittlich.


    Vielleicht ware irgendeine Normierung eine Idee? Ich denke noch daruber nach...

  • Zitat

    Original von garmt
    Das ist schwierig, denn nicht jeder Spieler spielt in allen Runden mit. Und es gibt Runden in den man einfach viele Punkte bekommt (wie diese 2. Runde: die Geschwister Jules Vernes und die Zusammenarbeit mit Laurie haben nur 4 bzw. 2 richtige Antworten). Macht jemand in solch eine 'schwierige' Runde nicht mit, so bekommt er einfach eine gute Position im allgemeinen Ranking. Und je mehr Leute in einer Runde teilnehmen, desto mehr Punkte bekommen sie durchschnittlich.


    Vielleicht ware irgendeine Normierung eine Idee? Ich denke noch daruber nach...


    Hm, die Nicht-Teilnehmer müssten irgendwie "Strafpunkte" bekommen...
    Oder man verteilt die Punkte anders:
    Bei 9 Teilnehmern erhält Platz eins 9 Punkte, Platz neun einen Punkt. Pro Teilnahme 1 oder zum Beispiel 5 Punkte extra. Die Antworten, die nur 1x abgegeben wurden, könnten ebenfalls 1 Punkt bekommen. Die fehlenden / falschen Antworten 1 Punkt Abzug. Am Ende gewinnt der mit den meisten Punkten.

  • Du hartnäckiger Ehrgeizling :rofl: ;) - willst mir wohl Strafpunkte aufhalsen? :dudu: - aber ich warne Dich, ich hab jetzt auch das Verne-Handbuch von Bertelsmann :D (das hast Du wohl nicht bedacht, als Du mir den Tip gabst? :harhar: ) - und warte nur ab, wenn ich erst die CD habe... :lol:


    Glückwunsch zum 6. Platz, lieber Poldi :) :up: :scheinheilig:

  • Zitat

    Original von Clavelina
    Du hartnäckiger Ehrgeizling :rofl: ;) - willst mir wohl Strafpunkte aufhalsen? :dudu: - aber ich warne Dich, ich hab jetzt auch das Verne-Handbuch von Bertelsmann :D (das hast Du wohl nicht bedacht, als Du mir den Tip gabst? :harhar: ) - und warte nur ab, wenn ich erst die CD habe... :lol:


    Glückwunsch zum 6. Platz, lieber Poldi :) :up: :scheinheilig:


    :DD ;)
    danke! :hi: